diff --git a/applications/lofar2/doc/prestudy/station2_sdp_transient_buffer.txt b/applications/lofar2/doc/prestudy/station2_sdp_transient_buffer.txt
index 7b11f321ca3c51170c2005b9d4d4002f59c736dd..4f7028dc031bdaa52e648e09a075ebd907349205 100644
--- a/applications/lofar2/doc/prestudy/station2_sdp_transient_buffer.txt
+++ b/applications/lofar2/doc/prestudy/station2_sdp_transient_buffer.txt
@@ -8,8 +8,9 @@ Detailed design: Transient Buffer (TBuf) function for LIFT project
4) TBuf (Transient Buffer) Design
5) TBuf ICD SC-SDP, SDPTR-SDPFW
6) TBuf ICD STAT/SDP-CEP
-7) Transient detection (TDet) Design
-8) Planning
+7) Crossbar
+10) Planning
+11) Transient detection (TDet) Design
References:
@@ -35,7 +36,7 @@ References:
- needs ring, because 6 antennas per event are typically not connected to one FPGA
-1) DDR4 memory per receiver input
+1a) DDR4 memory size per receiver input
Bottom up:
@@ -62,6 +63,13 @@ Defineer TBuf functie per receiver input:
. zodat de TBuf functie makkelijk uitbreidbaar is naar meer inputs en naar meer DDR4 modules.
. data capture en uitlezen van een receiver input onafhankelijk kan van de andere receiver inputs
+1b) DDR4 memory IO rate and data width
+The DDR4 IP runs at 800 MHz (minimum 625 MHz) so at DDR this yields 1600 MTps of DQ = 64 bit each.
+The DDR4 IP user rate is a quarter so 200 MHz.
+The factor is rsl = 1600 / 200 = 8, so therefore the controller data width is 8 * 64 = 512 bits.
+Using 800 MTps to have rsl = 4 and 256 controller data width is not possible, because the minimum
+DDR4 frequency is 625 MHz and because the user rate is fixed at a quarter.
+
2) Meeting EK-BH 24 okt 2022 [2]
Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
@@ -83,6 +91,7 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- Buffer lengte versus nof antennes
- Self trigger
+The CP FPGA_beamlet_output_nof_beamlets_RW is not supported in SDPTR and SDPFW yet. I was n
3) TBB (Transient Buffer Board) LOFAR1
- From 2.3 in [4]
@@ -96,9 +105,35 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- buffer raw data, no need to buffer subbands
-- choose fixe 14b data, so not e.g. 8 Msbits for lighting and 8 Lsbits for
+- choose fixed 14b data, so not e.g. 8 Msbits for lighting and 8 Lsbits for
cosmic ray. Always using full W_adc = 14b makes design and usage more clear.
+- choose to store data per antenna input, so dual polarion because:
+ . science always use both polarizations
+ . otherwise CEP will combine the two polarizations
+ . beamlets are also dual polarization
+
+- choose to record all antenna inputs per FPGA in parallel, instead of recording
+ control per antenna input:
+ . save FPGA logic and RAM resources by not having to implement a A_pn = 6 to 1
+ multiplexer with 6 * 512b --> 512b data widths
+ . allows record control per FPGA, so simpler CP and simpler memory access
+
+- choose to not provide a peek/pook MM access interface to DDR4
+ . Avoid implement a 2 to 1 multiplexer
+ . Logic MP are are sufficient, no need to MM read RSN in DDR4
+ . Dumping data is sufficient to read DDR4
+
+- choose to store RSN + samples + CRC in memory:
+ . CRC covers BSN + samples
+ . RSN can also be kept in logic and then derive other RSN from page index in memory,
+ but having RSN also in memory helps to make sure that the data is indeed of that
+ timestamp
+ . choose to use RSN and CRC per antenna input, so not one RSN for all
+ . pack antenna input from 28b to 64b to be able to prepend 64b RSN and append 64b CRC
+ per antenna input
+
+
- Station --> CEP --> Data Writer
. SDP output UDP directly to CEP or to LCU so that LCU can pass it on via TCP, to
recover from data loss
@@ -108,14 +143,14 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- treat all signal inputs independently (even though X and Y are always needed together)
- timing
- . Use sample sequence number (SSN) or mem_bsn:
- - SSN increments by nof_samples_per_page = 8176
+ . Use sample sequence number (RSN) or mem_bsn:
+ - RSN increments by nof_samples_per_page = 8176
- mem_bsn increments by 1 per page, so per block of nof_samples_per_page = 8176.
- . SSN counts sample periods (5 ns) since t_epoch = 1970, can fit
+ . RSN counts sample periods (5 ns) since t_epoch = 1970, can fit
2**64 / (365.25 * 24 * 3600 / 5e-9) > 2922 years
. TBuf uses sop and eop to mark nof_samples_per_page = 8176
. TBuf does not need sync ?
- . Start SSN or mem BSN at same time as SDP BSN by FPGA_processing_enable_RW.
+ . Start RSN or mem BSN at same time as SDP BSN by FPGA_processing_enable_RW.
- CP per signal input buffer
. flexible start and end address (so flexible buffer time per signal input)
@@ -127,46 +162,22 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- Block diagram:
- per si: pack 14b to 64b --> add mem hdr (= ssn or bsn) --> add crc --> pack 64b to 256b
+ per si: pack 14b to 64b --> add mem hdr (= rsn or bsn) --> add crc --> pack 64b to 256b
mux 12 si to 1 --> mux with + 1 MM --> write to DDR4
read from DDR4 --> demux to
. 1 MM
- . 1 retrieve --> unpack 256b to 64b --> check CRC --> add output hdr
- --> pass on via ring -->
- --> dump via 10GbE
+ . 1 dump --> unpack 256b to 64b --> check CRC --> add output hdr
+ --> pass on via ring -->
+ --> dump via 10GbE
- support MP on buffer state
. signal input index
. frozen, buffering, reading
. start address (time), end address (time)
-- unb2c_test_ddr_16G resource usage
- . git/hdl/boards/uniboard2c/designs/unb2c_test/revisions/unb2c_test_ddr_16G/unb2c_test_ddr_16G_resource_usage.jpg
- . DDR4 max_burst_size = 64 --> 64 * 256b words = 64 * 32B = 2 kB
- . M20k = 20 kbit = 2.5 kB
- . per module:
- wr_fifo 13 M20K
- tech_ddr 9 M20K
- rd_fifo 4 M20K
- diag db 0 M20K
- diag bg 0 M20K
- --> Total 26 M20K/DDR4 module
- . board common:
- MMM : 69 M20K voor Nios memory
- ctrl: 42 M20K voor MMAP ROM en 1GbE
-
-- Provide direct MM access interface to DDR4
- . New access multiplexer component (crossbar) to interface with io_ddr with:
- . write 12 signal input streams for TBuf recording + 1 MM write stream
- . read 1 stream for TBuf readout + 1 MM read stream
- . Write multiplexer for 12 + 1 = 13 inputs will take ~100 M20K,
- because it needs to multiplex and FIFO streams of 256 bit each and
- 256 bit requires 256 /40 = 7 M20K in parallel, so 13 * 7 = 91 M20K.
- . One M20K = 20b * 1024 words = 40b * 512 words, 512 words of 256b =
- 16 kByte, so FIFO can fit (almost) two 8 kB payloads, which seems
- sufficient.
+
- Use 1 DDR4 module / FPGA
. Because 16GB is enough for T_tbuf = 3.3 s
@@ -190,10 +201,10 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- packetize voor buffer write of na buffer read? --> voor
. packtetize at 64b or 256b ?
. 16b -> 64b packetize --> 64b --> 256b store
- . ddr page packet format: SSN + packed data + CRC
+ . ddr page packet format: RSN + packed data + CRC
- 8 KByte page to have integer number of pages (= slots) in 16G memory, so
that DDR4-I can wrap without a gap or extend to DDR-II without a gap.
- - SSN = 64b = 8B
+ - RSN = 64b = 8B
- 14b packed data
. nof_samples_per_page = 8K - 8 - 8 = 8192 - 16 = 8176 B / 14b = 4672
. 4672 * 5 ns = 23.36 us per page, so ~42.8 pages / ms
@@ -209,8 +220,8 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
. send packed 14b data
- 12 input multiplexer with 12 x 256b in and 256b out to write 256b words @ 200 MHz
-- use SSN as timestamp, SSN = BSN * N_fft, so can be derived from bsn_source BSN,
- or do we need a dp_ssn_source.vhd?
+- use RSN as timestamp, RSN = BSN * N_fft, so can be derived from bsn_source BSN,
+ or do we need a dp_rsn_source.vhd?
- store and send 14b packed data
. so do not use 16b (with 2b sign extension), to optimize for memory usage and
@@ -233,7 +244,7 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
circular buffer per si, wrap after nof_pages
keep track of nof_recorded pages, when > nof pages then circular buffer is
full and carries only fresh data
- keep track of ssn + page index of last recorded page
+ keep track of rsn + page index of last recorded page
@@ -251,43 +262,116 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
* In LOFAR1 bepaald LCU welke si uitgelezen moet worden richting CEP. De
TBB uP zorgt dan dat de nof pages verstuurd worden.
- . FPGA_tbuf_record_RW [pn][si] # True = start/continue, False = stop/freeze recording immediately
- . FPGA_tbuf_record_stop_timed_RW [pn][si] # Stop recording at specified SSN time, not needed for raw data ???
+ . FPGA_tbuf_record_enable_RW[pn] # True = start/continue, False = stop/freeze recording immediately
- . FPGA_tbuf_retrieve_inter_packet_gap_RW --> wait time between packets send to CEP in FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R units
- FPGA_tbuf_retrieve_timestamp_RW [pn][si]
- FPGA_tbuf_retrieve_nof_pre_pages_RW [pn][si]
- FPGA_tbuf_retrieve_nof_post_pages_RW [pn][si]
- . FPGA_tbuf_retrieve_enable_RW
- - total nof pages = nof_pre_pages + 1 (pointed by ssn) + nof_post_pages
+ . FPGA_tbuf_record_all_antenna_RW[pn] # True = record all antenna inputs, False = record only half of the antenna inputs, the once that have even index.
+
+
+
+ . FPGA_tbuf_dump_inter_packet_gap_RW --> wait time between packets send to CEP in FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R units
+ FPGA_tbuf_dump_timestamp_range_RW[pn][rsn] --> [0] = from rsn, [1] to rsn, SDPTR translates between float timestamp and int RSN
+ FPGA_tbuf_dump_enable_RW[pn][ai] --> boolean, SC takes care that only one global ai is TRUE
+ --> SC / dump tool loops global ai via FPGA_tbuf_dump_enable_RW and
+ FPGA_tbuf_dumping_R
+ --> SC / dump tool needs to take care that only one global ai is selected at
+ a time to avoid 10GbE link overload
+ --> use FPGA_tbuf_dumping_R to see when dump is busy or done, hoe als het heel snel klaar is ???
+
+ FPGA_tbuf_clear_total_counts_RW[pn] --> clear all TBuf total counts in pn
+
+ Not: FPGA_tbuf_dump_enable_RW[pn] -- antenna index
+ Not: TR_tbuf_dump_enable_RW -- antenna index
. FPGA_tbuf_output_hdr_eth_destination_mac_RW
. FPGA_tbuf_output_hdr_ip_destination_address_RW
. FPGA_tbuf_output_hdr_udp_destination_port_RW
- . FPGA_tbuf_output_enable_RW
-
- . FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW[pn]
- . FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_nof_words_RW[pn] --> read nof words (256b) from FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW
- FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_data_R[pn] --> read data results from FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_nof_words_RW
- . FPGA_tbuf_memory_write_data_words_RW[pn] --> write data words (256b) to FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW
+ . FPGA_tbuf_output_enable_RW[pn]
- Monitor Points (MP):
- . FPGA_tbuf_ddr4_present_R --> True is ddr4 memory is availabe, False is ddr4 calibration failed/ ddr4 not present
- . FPGA_tbuf_total_nof_pages_R --> 16GB / 8kB = 2M
- . FPGA_tbuf_page_size_R --> 8 kByte
- . FPGA_tbuf_nof_samples_per_page_R --> 4672 # = (8kB - 16) * 8b / 14b
- . FPGA_tbuf_nof_bits_per-sample_R --> 14 b
- . FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R --> 5 ns
-
- . FPGA_tbuf_page_period_R # = FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R * 23.36 us
- . FPGA_tbuf_recording_R [pn][si]
- . FPGA_tbuf_retrieving_R [pn][si] --> boolean of report remaining nof pages
+ * Raw data:
+ . FPGA_tbuf_nof_bits_per_sample_R --> 14 b = W_adc
+ . FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R --> 5 ns
+
+ * RSN monitor (dp_bsn_monitor)
+ . sync interval 1 s
+ . block size = 2000
+
+ * Memory (DDR4):
+
+ With streaming use of io_ddr then the dvr_wr_flush_en = '0' (so ctlr_wr_flush_en = 0 in MP), because
+ the sequencer takes of writing and reading blocks like in reorder_transpose.vhd. Use MP to check FIFOs.
+
+ Support onl MP for DDR4 module in slot I.
+
+ REG_IO_DDR_MB_I in io_ddr:
+ [3] RESIZE_UVEC(rd_fifo_full_reg & wr_fifo_full_reg, c_mem_reg_dat_w) # gets cleared upon read
+ [2] RESIZE_UVEC(ctlr_wr_fifo_usedw, c_mem_reg_dat_w) &
+ [1] RESIZE_UVEC(ctlr_rd_fifo_usedw, c_mem_reg_dat_w) &
+ [0] RESIZE_UVEC(ctlr_tech_mosi.wr & ctlr_tech_miso.rdval & ctlr_tech_miso.cal_fail & ctlr_tech_miso.cal_ok &
+ ctlr_rst_out_i & ctlr_wr_flush_en & ctlr_tech_miso.waitrequest_n & ctlr_tech_miso.done, c_mem_reg_dat_w);
+
+ Use ddr_ for DDR4 in slot I, in case in future DDR4 slot II is also used, then use e.g. ddr_ii for that module.
+ . FPGA_ddr_calibrated_R = cal_ok && !cal_fail --> True is ddr4 memory is available, False is ddr4 calibration failed or ddr4 not present
+ . FPGA_ddr_wr_fifo_full_R = wr_fifo_full_reg, True if write FIFO to ddr4 memory got full since last MP read, else False. Should remain False.
+ . FPGA_ddr_rd_fifo_full_R = rd_fifo_full_reg, True if read FIFO from ddr4 memory got full since last MP read, else False. Should remain False.
+ . FPGA_ddr_wr_fifo_usedw_R = ctlr_wr_fifo_usedw, current fill level of write FIFO to ddr4 memory in number of 512b words, should be 0 when not recording
+ . FPGA_ddr_rd_fifo_usedw_R = ctlr_rd_fifo_usedw, current fill level of read FIFO from ddr4 memory in number of 512b words, should be 0 when not dumping
+
+ No need for CP of:
+ - dvr_wr_flush_en, because io_ddr and DDR4 should work without need to flush when they operate OK.
+ No need to MP for:
+ - ctlr_tech_mosi.wr, because controlled by streaming sequencer
+ - ctlr_rst_out_i, because also used as reset for io_ddr itself
+ - ctlr_tech_miso.waitrequest_n ? could show hanging io_ddr_driver
+ - ctlr_tech_miso.done ? could show hanging io_ddr_driver
+
+ REG_TBUF_RAW new in node_sdp_transient_buffer_raw.vhd
+ . nof_bytes_in_ddr_R = 16 * 1024**3 (16GiB)
+ . nof_bytes_per_ddr_word_R = 64 Bytes (= 512b)
+ . nof_ddr_words_per_page_R = 657 or 329, depends on FPGA_tbuf_record_all_antenna_RW
+ ==> SDPTR: ddr_total_nof_pages = floor(nof_bytes_in_ddr_R / (nof_ddr_words_per_page_R * nof_bytes_per_ddr_word_R)
+
+ . last_recorded_page_index_R --> last page that was recorded in ddr, restarts at 0 when recording starts, increments during recording
+ . last_recorded_rsn_R --> RSN of block at last_recorded_page_index
+ . first_recorded_page_index_R --> restarts at 0 when recording starts, equals last_recorded_page_index + 1 when recording has
+ filled the circular buffer once and continues recording
+ . first_recorded_rsn_R --> RSN of block at first_recorded_page_index
+
+ SDPTR based on:
+ . FPGA_tbuf_dump_timestamp_range_RW[pn][rsn] (from_rsn, to_rsn)
+ . FPGA_tbuf_dump_enable_RW[pn][ai]
+ sets:
+ . dump_first_page_W = page index of from_rsn
+ . dump_nof_pages_W = nof pages in range from_rsn, to_rsn
+ . dump_antenna_input_W = active ai in FPGA_tbuf_dump_enable_RW
+ . dump_enable <-- enable to dump ai,
+
+ * Recording:
+ . FPGA_tbuf_recording_R[pn] --> pn is recording, all ai or half of ai (dependent on FPGA_tbuf_record_all_antenna_RW)
+
+ . FPGA_tbuf_last_timestamp_R[pn] = last_recorded_rsn * FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R
+ . FPGA_tbuf_first_timestamp_R[pn] = first_recorded_rsn * FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R
+ . FPGA_tbuf_recorded_time_R[pn] = FPGA_tbuf_last_timestamp_R - FPGA_tbuf_first_timestamp_R
+
+
+ * Dumping:
+ . FPGA_tbuf_dumping_R[pn] --> boolean or report remaining nof packets to predict when it will be done
+
+ . FPGA_tbuf_total_nof_memory_errors_R[pn][ai] --> count per ai, because each ai has own CRC
+ FPGA_tbuf_total_nof_dumped_packets_R[pn][ai] --> count per ai
Maybe:
- . FPGA_tbuf_last_page [pn][si] --> index of last recorded page
- . FPGA_tbuf_last_ssn [pn][si] --> ssn of last recorded page
- . FPGA_tbuf_nof_recorded_pages[pn][si] --> number of fresh recorded pages <= alloc nof_pages
+ . Not: FPGA_tbuf_last_page [pn][si] --> index of last recorded page
+ . Not: FPGA_tbuf_nof_recorded_pages[pn][si] --> number of fresh recorded pages <= alloc nof_pages
+
+
+ Not (no peek and poke):
+ . FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW[pn]
+ . FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_nof_words_RW[pn] --> read nof words (512b) from FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW
+ FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_data_R[pn] --> read data results from FPGA_tbuf_memory_read_nof_words_RW
+ . FPGA_tbuf_memory_write_data_words_RW[pn] --> write data words (512b) to FPGA_tbuf_memory_address_RW
+ Not: FPGA_tbuf_page_period_R # = FPGA_tbuf_sample_period_R * 23.36 us
6) TBuf ICD STAT/SDP-CEP
@@ -300,8 +384,8 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
. 8b rcu_id --> 8b signal_input_index (0-191)
. 8b sample_freq in MHz --> 1b f_adc sample period is 5 ns or 6.25 ns (as in beamlet packet)
. 32b seqnr --> not needed
- . 32b time in seconds --> 64b SSN = Sample Sequence Number
- . 32b samplenr in current sec --> 64b SSN = Sample Sequence Number
+ . 32b time in seconds --> 64b RSN = Sample Sequence Number
+ . 32b samplenr in current sec --> 64b RSN = Sample Sequence Number
10b bandnr + 22b slicenr --> for spectral data, not needed
. 512b bandsel --> for spectral data, not needed
. 16b spare
@@ -312,29 +396,26 @@ Design decision 16GByte DDR4 na L2SDP-854, 850
- beamlets application header fields (32 bytes = 4 * 64b)
- tbuf application header fields (20 bytes + 4 reserved bytes = 24 bytes = 3 * 64b):
- . 8b marker
+ ==> JDM: combine X and Y in one packet, like beamlets
+ ==> ETH CRC covers network errors, packet will get dropped in case of CRC error
+ . 8b marker ('t')
. 8b version_id
- . 16b station_id
+ - 32b observation_id --> like for beamlets, may be useful for cosmic ray piggy back, not in LOFAR1
+ . 16b station_info
+ - 1b hba_antenna_field (HBA-0, HBA-1)
+ - 15b station_id
. 16b source_info (as in beamlet packet)
- - 2b reserved
+ - 3b reserved
- 1b antenna_band_index (LB, HB)
- 2b nyquist_zone_index
- 1b f_adc --> sample clock rate, period is 5 ns or 6.25 ns
- - 1b memory_error --> based on DDR4 read CRC
- 4b sample_width --> 14b, where 16b is represented by 0
- 5b gn_index --> purpose fault analysis
. 32b reserved
- . 8b signal_input_index --> 0..191
+ . 8b signal_input_index --> 0..191 ==> antenna_input_index 0..95
. 16b nof_samples_per_packet --> (8kB - 16) / 14b = 4672 (= 1022 words of 64b) --> log2() = 13b
- . 24b nof_packets_remaining in current dump (log2(2M pages) = 21b ??? to detect lost packets and progress
- . 64b SSN = Sample Sequence Number
+ . 64b RSN = Sample Sequence Number --> is prefered over a BSN, because RSN can start at any sample, whereas a BSN has to fit start at 1970.
-Not needed ???:
- - 32b observation_id --> like for beamlets, not needed, also not in LOFAR1
- - 1b udp_error --> based on ETH/IP/UDP CRC error in case LCU does UDP to TCP,
- no needed, because CRC error packets will be dropped
- - header_crc (covered by eth crc)
- - payload_crc (covered by eth crc and by memory_error bit)
- headers: 14 + 20 + 8 + 24 = 66 bytes
crc: 4 bytes
@@ -343,26 +424,31 @@ Not needed ???:
--> packet overhead is (66 + 4) / 8246 = 0.85 %
-7) Transient detection (TDet) Design
+SigMF:
-- no self triggering yet for MVP
+Tammo Jan 25 nov 2022:
-- will use Hilbert transform of real input and > 30MHz BPF
- https://nl.mathworks.com/help/signal/ug/single-sideband-modulation-via-the-hilbert-transform.html
- For the FIR Hilbert transformer we will use an odd length filter which is
- computationally more efficient than an even length filter. Albeit even
- length filters enjoy smaller passband errors. The savings in odd length
- filters is a result that these filters have several of the coefficients that
- are zero. Also, using an odd length filter will require a shift by an
- integer time delay, as opposed to a fractional time delay that is required
- by an even length filter. For an odd length filter, the magnitude response
- of a Hilbert Transformer is zero for w=0 and w=Ï€. For even length filers the
- magnitude response doesn't have to be 0 at π, therefore they have increased
- bandwidths. So for odd length filters the useful bandwidth is limited to
- 0 < w < π.
+Hoi Eric, over het opslaan van complex voltage data, dat ik gisteren tijdens de group meeting even noemde: het metadataformaat heet SigMF. . Het is gewoon een json-bestandje dat je naast een databestand met alleen complex voltages opslaat. Een prima viewer hiervoor is inspectrum ( https://github.com/miek/inspectrum ). Als data formaat voor streaming complex voltages gebruiken we difi (een subset van vita49) over ZeroMQ.
+
+
+7) Crossbar
+
+* It is not possible to combine 3 * 12 * 14b = 3 * 168b = 514b into one controller word,
+ because it must be possible to individually record and stop signal inputs. Therefore
+ it is not possible to multiplex all signal inputs per controller word. Instead each
+ controller word should contain only write data from one signal input.
+* Each burst of controller word also shoul contain write data from one signal input. The
+ maximum burst size is 64 (= 2**7 - 1 = 63) controller words 64 * 512b / 8b = 4kB. Actual burst
+ size can be between 1 and 63.
-8) Planning
+
+* Using burstcount = 1 yields 512b / 14b = 36 * 14b samples + 8b not used per controller word.
+ Burstcount > 4 is probably needed for sufficient efficiency.
+ efficiency = n / (n + CAS + command latency) = n / (n + 1.5 + 9), n = burstcount for read
+
+
+10) Planning
- ICD STAT-CEP --> tbuf packet format
- ICD SC-SDP --> OPC-UA CP and MP
@@ -385,3 +471,22 @@ Not needed ???:
- Verify TBuf within SDP on HW
- Integration effort with SC
+11) Transient detection (TDet) Design
+
+- no self triggering yet for MVP
+
+- will use Hilbert transform of real input and > 30MHz BPF
+ https://nl.mathworks.com/help/signal/ug/single-sideband-modulation-via-the-hilbert-transform.html
+ For the FIR Hilbert transformer we will use an odd length filter which is
+ computationally more efficient than an even length filter. Albeit even
+ length filters enjoy smaller passband errors. The savings in odd length
+ filters is a result that these filters have several of the coefficients that
+ are zero. Also, using an odd length filter will require a shift by an
+ integer time delay, as opposed to a fractional time delay that is required
+ by an even length filter. For an odd length filter, the magnitude response
+ of a Hilbert Transformer is zero for w=0 and w=Ï€. For even length filers the
+ magnitude response doesn't have to be 0 at π, therefore they have increased
+ bandwidths. So for odd length filters the useful bandwidth is limited to
+ 0 < w < π.
+
+