From 69d26f9a25f81bf42c72a5f415be752d78533e9c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Jan David Mol <mol@astron.nl>
Date: Tue, 8 Feb 2011 00:42:26 +0000
Subject: [PATCH] bug 1362: paper update, final submission europar 2011

---
 doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.pdf | Bin 750936 -> 750940 bytes
 doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.tex |   2 +-
 2 files changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)

diff --git a/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.pdf b/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.pdf
index 80cc6d9faaea993ef4bf8bdfe469ce9efea93da5..933790a29f9d453fe224acfb4b15b894ec7e3657 100644
GIT binary patch
delta 4346
zcmah~2{ct}8%D`+3aJc9p+qA4?0HipL+F%CC`~daLqciNrj*JMQpb?`5i*`a#ttQg
z4CM+HsSKGDbt+fs-*s>I-uC&|`p;Ttopql5z2Eb`&-=XZembPpIiwX7A{ZhRG9zSW
zh;YcP5RnkkLNPz4AaUW2iaMK&6%{5+=2U#*yi;9Jnw8tO{h)XJNP~4hSn#Z?QMoSo
zlKb}7{N6LafB0A_86+9I#4^KbmF!)~Wu_+tMAf$~l4<T9HoP{P!4A#PHoN&WB=JN7
z`>V>Pf*YC>#+LIPq*cS%FS?f)w2yh(7l-<knztNyhYbsU@CYrsb@4#chp~DU$;D)_
zmzRr)TWNvV=~Uq|=%k=(%vy={P|%U=#0M5zu5m)|7U|sByyDi;ozug89RFCGMWKnS
zYYraPuXCMO_~K6W!eOwx!ED7&*&UET4vXRFaaZTl3-6qfP0ayGx<d_Fx=A&6XCG)E
zirL5W88KOa#cgSxE4gM{0W0NI%~a!Q2I*M>UL3g*exkr@BlM*0)Bx$R@^y8vLlW?0
zw7J{5Iy2H~YDgeqmoU#?o(I;QTvCrq_KG%m2gJ4XNQ}N6R|$W>eQEYA;A;oyx_iBf
ztAArabnkJ<XtjRejOK&73J+s(24;6qcZ|Vlt7~L;tun7@PUaNnWJcc-kCnWfPTqHk
z^UNH!Piz|T7Y(~-Hs-Q!EJtiJ=GvjoD)wJ2^4O+*`=^0^UYjGAd-?XlvaUM9)=y-v
zO`4g(x@}v+%%5%CQ>uMn?DTq|Zz3+LKx$sc(zQE-ujhJ|eH7rN<ZYegnaXLKB+QFj
z-;=jq)<@1UsxKdEvQLon-Nn)|^=%~uUzG`83mDqsIy9oW#H>V7siW-XmZCE0{pGgG
zw?eH(1f@DPWiQ&C?o61Lo1yS1dAVqzpU9c2W$n3k(p6|uzpQ@AbF;j?Hia|Lq;N!D
zXv%omnq6%RJ~$ueSo93;vOoNIINeN5+ElbVwdoKhamDp!m+hrjMWRt1DSDaHo@BOQ
zy5VPbLdsg`zU7tu*79x(Jyg|wEE)zAzCKbnuN?`B32%LzyZc!6eA#bYorI6Omk4qd
zhllVCNAc(R&u+0tQ`HP}6>m$PP>oKM>yZy!<fB-fhy-yu)MSN@#`g}sU>@QkKH3T;
zvSpFY>)teU=`WS``Fv(FzkJ-sIU$_9sG{{a-P_)vw0TbY8_^~%+yKO;=?i6x6qZzO
z<!W8I-N13W*paxVMxi21{C42Wq}Z7DlPe;0pef9;+U%X{YstEh&a<x9)v{yXHH|o(
zFYwJ+{MdUiKgX+ia1VQpY0-wmu4j%1bJdEmdVygxS<d##bF(8)TG(H$c=SNFjC^{b
zLZm%9z6U8XALn`*`C;d4?%z$>uy*3n+_{le_wOj%miHLT-|`YU6dpG-4VkprW~jhI
z9pVRPt*Eif>sCK^g6$F?tzG=KlUH_w{QY>!hpNn+Zd+Scep|w#K?XPZQ<|}ElH<t@
zt{NxD0r)*w-<#w%T%S`CC$Ql~YAz`v68yz?wNT4Uwf1(SH#~96!pGd&yL-9=f8*JS
zdhyP0IOn8UsgC%{rd9N=tJ?H7{y%xX!WV(h&1JdW)5$W?<mB{+FFV!z1Li5Nsd)3B
zq%38NG<V`9^UbPuPY1tM*Eo7NJ=&aO#(8^A8!GxvrW+hI!IUp;R0nlcnt0Eo$&Qp_
z1+52l)1oCjX(9C}#T>(jDkqMxqUPH~JukJ4nf><FF{8B+n$fMF9pq%x))u6>*xHU9
z*N@i(mk0TbnJz7lDzDJZp3fCadDXb32`frf*qGYocA0l9HTy{yv@z_-wxZNLQ`>|4
zS6^1L+-KHvgSFwZ+Lp?xCfy>gXX!9$F>902iD{Ph%kpe}pWDmQhMebElKu7lcClH>
zj;2<&=7>&ENu%|yfv+xeg~IKP(reQuzr>u~T%)bN`GXP?(V7!plfUco5^w+c$Fy1t
zPnpP@JC(O~1{S@@%rmMJ7O|Fa^_KF8JlQV;?6@LeH!}BCqH%Vn(5&lMfxQEn98z^a
zdXxMDU(m7cO34B*sTS@9*(3q;<y(DX^;<W@)bwAjpNM8<1V1X-e2zO2Bi%QQrh9T`
zSk6lib~8w089RIt`K@-iC3B(kxWwT@S<6R-E3evlu)_x`U3YR4W@hZy%N!g`PyZYp
za}$})3JkpX$F^h+xAeD5Ha1RUcNP?rX50>`_Zl(-QmcfR4KJmFCv3$}?Wwvgv9?t%
zpisx|Vc)mtTkn@1DlE4=$;QD}mi4;5&8D@z@<vPTt@o|5yI1$eS%C<Vsk}-t?Z|3W
z$EKKNy)Uc%TaR7iy{#{%IwWn+jv~odKLx~mdN<jpyqwvrvg?|qyiDJbxw2-aeP78G
zoi$&kl*Q}SpVgjOX|?tE6(Ng98NBX{x3As)INbKIe#cI+`|HmSJF!-}S;h?(OsDC+
z^D|f&F_>%@3XQ9;xTmS%t{fkf5xpsJh5YrF$c$X0Ub#9Qryc%yRJX3x_N*I;3hnC#
zrCnA|yua(FuNQRm=%`6QlyPZu%DtyOEk@+^R*(3QM0{uU;khP*{^oP$`<r;T1?wKv
zd^b8hr*cu)tc^7q*H&L`6zq#~&yN=}3YozS0T1{QQhqNZZJ(vKfN>gO#Ovbq%a1%i
zf9YvB@fCb8D!1=gp6VUm9mxshuhLOQld%#d`pJ)$9A6l#IomnG9iGvrk-s=%(q&-R
zeNwEmQ|t=q+Qq5Va?)AaSX-;NOxU@5Z`OyahJ{zvkBX=kS5@;iy;*>ahVkMZqM!6D
zv377Ce0BHuJuy-*(dFi-bNq3hgJVa8)|Q(rQf8x@RsVzt;{m?TZ+nQC=&FJ@MwP8G
z{u7={n&M;_53d)kk@s8(D99Cy_OtE}y10{A0JkNh3|<vD={_oPT6Rj(bo`6RvJ+|I
zX&+N(m_}^vJrvNQQr?>%-t{IweDzqfjQqBmv76tDY6Vsv)iaFc$avV#$|)$-g2)YQ
ziz6;eyYqVW;j-|@-v*W)y3zL8Q(3F+Y=*Y;V$|HMGeu@_RA=0#YMXXca-LULzipzP
zS%Zs<RH)TZs+@@R*e%67%!uKjf%c15mGkCrKA=}{=D{p<+z1q#bd?=07ORr5o)<ai
zRNQMtfkegw)>T&eqk)RFni2i+ahS_~w_I#~sJo6B^%XC6*I``Om<d5JaRC4qvb9|p
z!ax48aTmr%l28J^f0VqH#J~SyFoJ<hI)(x$&WC{je=JUbeCH_QUoikc0TBKZE6#Og
z_y}u2d|?O(AisuTFiIuIUhm1+D2oCR{UMCOaB;RL!%9$t0DgUlG7+54fC4av5o|SY
zh8jt$jjEO)FxnLW2Ec#i{8KBGQVXP00T{~Ui^cy(EDkaM(uMrzLL5Q)NGMHd#iC3A
z1!<z9OeRFo6hoOfj-j+dASML;dLId(FbLBXrGhb(??Qxt`P>2HI4x<)MG!_$5Cm|X
z)@BrB0uYm=Wk`V-y(J(M=1T@-VoZ8<Aa#(B7=#geAs~qTUC6$_ypMvEHhjbg#E+pU
zM!ygO34)#s1TkU0a}bjq?ZcQyB76c-L?GW4RA*>{qY#Y1bc;bS&gT*cVPbT9LKyTX
zM*cJND1;+?-lj$kpeIAg$Y(JaL=bvcVFKi{CrmJz|JIh`r)-DdKNrEz8K9<^Y9Y-L
zFagn*5=vowvqE9`ze#>@P>!WL0wxd==BtjtiC+hUN{}FMx`YTo^_7+&@_mH(F_cb>
zFsVWNagO|Z<)R1^p|4jIp>p9PCYXGlK`GPHy?~-H-~6CB{Hu>B{ZSOB!f9D!0Ep1#
zr&b?9uNZ?MfFDB;K8*4uT?Gt>36f5XQwxz^F^;1Uy-frR(AN!0zz|3qGz`EIx@Rbi
z`1w}(d+A~z4&$`GV;}+i;?^H;Mru512~w{l1fx|<VbnnVs_J*_-wOKsI<Tw#8Sri<
zh8r0e;sk;i7=s`Lo2)aSUYCZ3FpL<PfH<nBwEF)Z*{P(bC+_F(;Ol?L*Tq$w;vx`S
LTvgTB!bJSP#ts%Q

delta 4293
zcmah~2{@E{7f%Q?xkw>YB!uwJyAR4PrHBY!E!HSYwiZ`j`>w8aaLZO{k!%$y%T0(3
z)kH}uQCZ4znHEyt+t=NC=X;)So@bt!=lsw4|IYcH-#P!MqneLLHN&I%q8CQ<M+-y?
zMlXsMiWa^i63E~~SQ4EgYl##Gi@?DeiTXMF;WV0^GAA^>-A7dydgbJSj`ho@$t%#(
z9E#0j6k5lK{P8cc8E=cWt7Xzs#0>cRhoxmokC%9Ixmpk2b2$A?tTPTiO+JQfj`Ol}
zjt)|vF0M@k64JUkVcf2QRqqdZ*1FczTXEDs-rz2nO)>84eWJ53mUtALDkQg8_vhc*
z9LK$*rraXN*`5X>s=p4lB^T_@y~e$}Y<aH#l~a~)Gc5-59(@g)l}iX%)jEK7`8#c}
zs_b91OCPj$-eY!>sd0AB<ze!I1DuG*j*EB2hUs@7DjP1jd@9JjKVO^U*-|_abeH9!
z$4#%4V^<BwpUb=CsA@e)4072Kbom<e>dErt$fS2$bkUxeVPb6m@&x`S9q04<1u?d;
zO@8rsFCQEQ$_|6M!D&MJJ^m}>h4r4ktMF)C@nrsWd-ChL`oVzVI96~+W1hph;oOPU
zZS&6YM?ya?DjNHMW+?kh`BuGsSF3&VXKidx$c?q1%vuY3D~eTm2=#4J_|~K`m}#T0
zS6$aTw$wvt)AQ-*XO5D^UhK<u*}fxSO2JrIx$od3(H@tEDD&MX=3kf`pHnt8vGcMK
zPwzyEYz|328MlCH{G$x7>#3MX$=;q4-e#|`e_vm{?yZvZ8au*tC0mkmUMK&a?q6L+
z#}|wK`l=Gr+LJ32u$$=6F%RhGdr{1P=J4oYkI|RwlGdDFuh4hh>z;G4vg|wEn1?Gj
zR|pv#ta7s5As299*7YZEy|~=Qds-smF`F)LthycTqtjIub}%r_sr#a*n0Hn(vV7s3
z9qw~^juwIv@SBm(yZ0Ogh6^{TE-@E&v6j9m7kSR{Qgx<sjpo9kYs7i0iw%!MqDREP
zoGn~?uhT!n{$xgL%<G*Zw5O7RwJW~ZFI9FsWRTE0|M+>+N6&3epHIxX)t>HO5W+;b
zUYnYiUU^lX`R3heRpV1D>cm{kS7V}Eq-PZOF1y`FYkbrnMUPm|{yZ}-b923{S((t0
zt}BW6Bj4QW)mK__@MHX^$~j`>h)ZsA=4#D**GBRTueYTX4+wYG!5u*6b-!>#Y3I{D
zm!3&=?SB2CLPsZ?zg4b2N!B&4P+vp2H%cu<hyDh0xxH!9Wk9Sg`KBxTp1}^afm3l-
z{BEx-p`!l#?v8zh9FCgMuimUQkNB|2I#oZvEWVy}-)BK#(mC=%`Slx!&^^i8K^6Ph
zLe;4`gUIpCQ*{SS1O3ukyMHe_VDQICyzs^Wmm%?z{*jBxEr*o!%(g_f=YB4}RLHN=
zSKcubZaa8sVsLF@<hkISRPDp#55#IKti1HMA05cBpUSe|a#LONIBe{v))3^mPwiTb
zTQMjjW=zj<l$w|?_wZ<L79g_6_<SH8V5p;luUOFXa<55`D9!rHy{h=VS0;~b<Jt+Y
z;C3BIbnR$Ziv&oY^$1XOR-F(s?0-mWcb=)@IyBFjXs-J@J3laWLu>fCW>7{b+gdl+
zB5(8EfO^+UyX?K4Ews)!=EutQxTQ^TJ!6bl1bn(?8f=CsW^G-ouDhDhVmCi1H}%tZ
z>`0%MnC!6-E-*NB<tODNK(^dqv#p`*8x=LMhW}H1xNMG6$y5`t&NAF%W8c%CE9RQK
zE6-;yxK*c=^44fP?n{x=j7oeY_8foyaH}s^8j|ndb3(5F>{OnYPDW3Fe6VR{Wyzpn
zq)DA}N)xE5XmvU4!zn9oLWmile^T^hyv)2w&O|q|3g4afVC>Ao5@Pbzw7Potq>H)D
zj?L?t;WcbqaAu%Zgs;VKwZ+hb&|_`4ufJK`zEt_lwW~Wbr<{6{ra38{k!5FhUc0x>
z*xj3G2+H3@`0lq3_?<5^Do3t4cko38|6-P^0ou19w8HbMZKD8J(u@#2J8KrHHDGI9
zsB&77DOp`4DjQTbWV$chMnp>fRTn$=W5r1eyAAMm!Sgke7t{OK^dJp=OCCOrvW)gE
zX%st}xx@BGGqF(6hkf7hv2H5M;F!R$RGD<o&bh>K#}8Wkor;Q$`8ykgM(+qRCTTLV
zGDfo2^R|yTjh}RlLR=RUNA*I|=__JC9*y&=A4-Jjv^D-l4l@fzdur0VoBt4h<{HlJ
z%sw6WJZ!)IHr?J<gMde~@@poteeyhQBS+)*9jIBXFIkWmHXMgVG~HJz)oM=7k=-)?
znOM`Im)z~&FuynRv7rUm-AX0waDM){i;HCGOFP+2XX_m$HReVkHALCybU!g(RGyqx
z+EJtEey42vi-9Sp(y;M~u)_RRwIB2*{IXvLwv@_DcRDWh$SrSxH(Cmuxu0!gzD&y`
z_srs|^Jh}r_|jHxI(BUFwsXIA>Ly%ev>$Bw$Q&?8w7*kgol|$+@z}y$gZs9w)SIns
ziSzI)n;#0@`p~~3@Z_S<AVQeCYp2QpYH9DkJK9>u;(}th+fXs>>4kl<+7ngNcI$HC
zB)dCJzf{ypDstR(iOK{8apNQ5zGVxihVQnGP7cjPSop<$eN`l$GyF+!_J~Kv2*wiK
z>o(z(G}o7~%2sE##i}UOa%Nn6cv|(8)Cq}2V5#Dh)QjT1CtiQndEZ666!6^?*}CV*
z+v?|!7;WYnV5OMacy^7W`h2VSJJpMK4ckfq|6kJFP1$c;j(I#@!|fK7tiIt-Y{;GQ
zxGz1XdhOIY&IEJI+t~|)AJjPcrktFcdp~U#aFw6Bu6av9K))c%p#iqB{A2&B&TJ`q
z`*3#%io<(Rz*pjFP9kTF=<yv1d2`~Rm(y(A*{i?E?0%~++I%-ZRygZ}^3_!$3is>o
zq*`-U-`H^>xxUn9`BA+BP4LQbsPyapI}0>^x&A(VLLyUpvc!Ajj$ZxgyQ+1S68`p;
z+H5VQ8T~YY7@ruiB@bNkk9>Lm%K3E0ZO#4GH9Hc@zG~DN#Liwmw(E({m(4?2nTGQ1
zN-Mj(4cLZ#5=zCv>&54NZAPWTUBV7)dlywiY}HF`H>z)Gp6!k(SE_qooMqJUkrvJt
z419e;aat(gxeYj{U3yg`kj1bSk&N@!5h1^{YHuC-1$6<C381X0^CBw+8UOvO=T3j`
zjwk@%J_^1Hv~Rx{j9?6mYC{1O=COeQZ!C`EJbn<2RI@zjiGu1N&mjT=44wcOfmjya
z^sUkelSw^<F&L;W^QPPIspII6hbRNVsR$?lV;I8H@TIE~lnTh2m`sRr1%LrCz+;0M
zR44#L89cH0|A@sQ#-A(^e^HDAID+zk;7kUkSd;;vAcbO-!GM?)#!v>1V<07Ihyj5=
z-seU35QM0VlEGvtlwbzJgm^Rn<2WU0QY#QfO%Mcd)_@;fk^n%;6)4Cc<wb!4888n#
z$iNuXdO*^V2MUA{YU&_}eNUbEN7E=svcUt4K)f~-#i$pOG%~5lKoA4w@q@@V{Hr(;
zA3z}p;UNfuaFFLhvNKe+$gzQ`5`$ozM<o!#K&kSCFo@ta;s}qn$!Q0u$-oH0BQY36
z;D1;5tvHwo^2ifrG8o^PCjMS2C``^Jk91&C4gaF+`-Kp7^^hPC&#aI(oZ3#93I8={
z-{*|vpA1G|p6Zx5{^MYL^J8LE3K0O}5imk_l*$5WL#e_<7$C_%r8<OxP?so*;7pLm
zkICTC3`$Cvss$7!cOeCXe9ivS(Ld`3#Yr5BBiVI?N<X>!aH<F~QvSR)1m>~fAoL>(
z1b|{VxicuhI1T~Sig6r;sBL1x0CnA<Oc(+wV~3Hul&Trh#snC|kH8p+!x*LS82JkR
zsn);6iop<0-S!xaA}FO|(uPv^$2Z&G46<$o(RGX=3<QkKKpemgL6Qt3%m^_ug$>DP
e5&?`&O^h}u=>0zzmVPjOnJ`RKRyMUVqx}bOoDqKj

diff --git a/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.tex b/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.tex
index 51466b7cc89..d0982bf4d61 100644
--- a/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.tex
+++ b/doc/papers/2011/europar/lofar.tex
@@ -202,7 +202,7 @@ Once an output core has received and reordered all of its data, the data are sen
 \section{Performance Analysis}
 \label{Sec:performance}
 
-We will focus our performance analysis on the most challenging cases that are of astronomical interest. In all cases, we respect the real-time nature of our system by limiting the load such that there is at most 0.1\% of data loss, but typically much less. Almost all variance occurs in the networks within the BG/P due to clashes caused by scheduling intricacies. We present measurements for a single BG/P rack.
+We will focus our performance analysis on the most challenging cases that are of astronomical interest. In all cases, we respect the real-time nature of our system by limiting the load such that there is at most 0.1\% of data loss, but typically, data loss is much rarer. Almost all variance occurs in the networks within the BG/P due to clashes caused by scheduling intricacies. We present measurements for a single BG/P rack.
 
 \subsection{Overall Performance}
 
-- 
GitLab